Follow-Up

I write articles and stories for a wide variety of outlets. Sometimes when I fail to gain the attention of a publisher, I drop the article into my personal blog you’re reading now. I’ve written a few pieces on the on-going saga of Kilmar Abrego Garcia and as you can see in the comments, I have few supporters. The last article I posted here was rejected by the publisher of a blog site called AmericanThinker.com. In the editors rejection notes to me, we had a spirited back-and-forth that I thought you might enjoy reading so I have copied and pasted it below. Looks like I’m hitting nerves!

On Thu, Aug 28, 2025 at 8:15 AM Bob <hmrun123@aol.com> wrote:

You argued with me about this some months ago and come to find out you were wrong.  Maybe now this is timely?

Bob:

I’m afraid that pillorying the Trump administration on behalf of a gangster and human trafficker is not something that will play with AT readers. We’re going to pass. 

Best,

JR Dunn

On Fri, Aug 29, 2025 at 8:27 AM Bob <hmrun123@aol.com> wrote:

JR:

There is nothing in what I wrote that is incorrect factually.  Gangster?  Zero proof.  Human Trafficker, again zero proof, read what I wrote.  If you’re a Trump at all costs guy, you’re really not doing your readers any service feeding them only what they want to hear.  There a many flavors of ice cream, seems you’re hooked on plain vanilla. 

 “And immediately there fell from his eyes as it had been scales: and he received sight forthwith”

In a message dated 8/30/2025 7:04:42 AM Eastern Daylight Time, jrdunn@americanthinker.com writes:

— JR Dunn 

Bob:

I’ll stick with plain vanilla rather than the Ben & Jerry’s Diesel Oil with Sea Slugs that’s being presented here. 

BTW, a colleague reminded me that we should add “wife beater” to “gangster” and “human trafficker.” 

JR:

Here it is in its simplest form:  Are you familiar with the legal concept known as the “fruit of the poisonous tree” doctrine?  If not, Google it.  Had the administration not erred in grabbing Garcia up and unlawfully taking him to prison in the first place, (Which BTW they admitted doing) none of what followed would have taken place.  What followed was literally the fruit of the poisonous tree.

Don’t EVER declare in your writings that, “we are a nation of laws” or otherwise tout lawfulness when you approve of trampling all over civil and constitutional rights as a necessary casualty of getting to the outcome you have pretended to envision as the right one.  Your position in this case is one of a dogmatic ideologue suffering from cognitive dissonance.  (Thankfully, this can be treated.)  

Thank you for making my point so vividly in your tortured defense calling for crucifixion via the publics ignorance of due process and making your case only attractive in the public square of group-think low-information consumers of news. 

You and your colleague ought to sign up for a Constitutional Law course in order to elucidate yourselves.  I’ll take as convincingly persuasive, the quotes I reference from members of the judiciary over your tepid and unsupported utterances passing as authoritative.

If you had any creative courage at all, you would publish what I wrote with your 2-cent warning label about how full of crap you think I am, but reminding readers about how you are of a big enough mind to put what I wrote out there to see what others might think.  One would think you would relish watching me get flamed?  It seems to me that you’re all about reinforcing your opinions rather than exploring alternatives.  Not really so courageous.

Standard

And Then, the Line Went Dead

I have seventeen entries in my cell phone directory of people who are dead.  Sixteen men and one woman.  My oldest and best friend Mike, gone too soon and in the midst of a dispute we never quite settled, then his wife Nancy, just a few years later, succumbing to breast cancer after deciding to forgo chemo for fear of losing her hair.

Two guys I met playing squash, one a complete crazy person, but in a good way, Paul and I traveled, quite literally around the world together, from NY west, bouncing off countries and continents until arriving back where we started.  His last words to me were that he would kick my ass in squash, days later dying of complications from prostate cancer.

The other gentleman, Joe, was one of my favorite mentors, a masterful attorney and finally a judge, falling too early to the ravages of Parkinson disease and the pleasant indignities of our final lunch together where I had to wipe food from his mouth as he somehow smiled.  I helped to carry him to his grave.

Then Sal, my favorite attorney and one of the brightest men I ever met, he came out of retirement in his mid-70’s because the stock market had crashed, ruining his savings.  This man slept in his office during the week and retreated to his home in the Pocono Mountains on the weekends.  He once kicked a young man-potential client out of his office because he was being rude to his mother.  His wife called me with the sad news of his passing.

Poor Rodney, the black handyman, he did lots of work on my house and my office over the years and we argued mightily about the prospects of an Obama presidency but always respectfully.  Rodney had a young son he would bring along sometimes to the job, a respectful and very polite boy that lost his dad way too early.

Dick, an older man, never married, a modest, middle-class bon vivant and regular visitor to all of the local and popular bars, yet did not himself partake of intoxicants, he rather more enjoyed the camaraderie and socializing.  If you got him going on a historical topic, he would laugh and remember it with fondness and if saddened he was quick to shed a tear, he was a very nice and humble man.  Cause of death unknown to me, he was in his 80’s and reportedly an excellent baseball infielder in his day.

My good friend Patrick, dead in his mid-40’s, reportedly falling down the stairs at home.  “Bones” as he was known, struck and killed a police officer with his car and spend 4-years in prison where he helped to teach young men how to tell time and how to play a higher level of softball.  A rabid Met’s fan and a chronic gambler, he could tell you more baseball stats that a Google search.  A great guy that everyone loved, but tragically failed to launch.

Joe, a man of a bygone era; a husky, handsome Italian real estate man with plenty of friends in all sorts of places, his collection of finely crafted Italian suits was impressive.  Every time I had an article published in the local newspaper, Joe would be the first call I got and every time he would begin by telling me that whatever it was I had written about was, “outstanding”  He never missed an afternoon at the YMCA.

Steve, the little guy who was always tagging along until that time when he went into the Navy and came back the man we all looked up to, literally, as he was 6’5” and 240 pounds of military muscle.  At 40-something he was diagnosed with a rare lung disorder that ended up taking his life on the operating table as they tried a risky procedure that ultimately failed.  I’ll never forget the look in his eyes on our last meeting as he described what he was about to undergo.  I brought my 15-year old son along for that visit in the effort to show him what the difficulties in life look like close up.  It was to be our last meeting.

Another Steve, this one the younger brother of my childhood sweetheart, a brilliant boy that never quite accepted the realities of adulthood, this guy was a magnificent painter, a writer and a musician that embraced the drug culture and all of the illness that came with it, he left behind two children and a sorrowful family that witnessed the sadness of a brothers failure to thrive into his potential.

Then there was Tom, retired early from a state job, loved bragging about sloughing off at work then spent his time drinking beer and smoking pot, heart-attack killed him in his early 60’s before he could figure out how to be a grandpa.

The latest death, my Uncle Tom happened only a few months ago.  We were pretty close, he used to beat me at chess pretty regularly until one day I got lucky and beat him.  Funny thing about it, he realized it before I did because he was such a better player and saw the game far ahead of me.  His death was a real unusual event as he went into the hospital short of breath and at first the docs thought he was headed home after a few medicine adjustments and then all of a sudden he was instead headed to hospice care.  He didn’t even seem that sick and was just basically waiting to die.  Before he did, we talked a lot and he shared with me the book that unlocked his drawing talent.  About a week before he passed, I asked him to draw me and he did.  He was a great guy, a true man of God and a really deep and critical thinker.  When I slow down a bit, I’ll examine that book.

Two of my buddy’s dads are in there, a former limo driver I used to hire for trips to New York, and finally, the brother of an acquaintice that I ended up liking more than I did his brother.

I don’t have the heart to take any of them out of my phone.  Not doing so somehow lessens the finality of what death really is and I’m always happy, and then a little sad, to see their names pop up.

Standard